15
« on: November 01, 2012, 11:39:07 pm »
A few people have raised some interesting points here.
Brad Z states that the 5th place at Petit Le Mans "should really shut the doubters up", and "is faster on the back straight than an LMP1" Well I think not I am afraid. I am not going to criticise the design of the car, because clearly Ben is a very clever man, and has come up with a very clever design that works, but what is it for? I have always been sceptical of the DW, simply because I could not see what it was for and what it was trying to achieve. A 5th place at Petit is great if you were an underdog or small private team running in LMP1 or 2, to the same rules that everybody else is running to , but to invent your own class and then say how well you are doing against everybody else does not bear comparison. How about if we were to invent another class for F1 cars, and then how many people would shout about how much grip they had in the corners? If a 500kg class were to be introduced, with more open rules than we have at the moment where designers were allowed more scope for development, I am sure we could see other designs embracing new technology, as the DW does not use new technology, it is a new concept using current technology in a new way. Remember, this is one of the four Aston Martin AMR One chassis that didn't work in LMP1 last year.
I do agree with GF that the design of the DW has challenged the accepted philosophy of how a car should work. However, in racing, you design a car to the published regulations, and the DW car is not designed to any regulations. Again, if you gave a blank sheet of paper to all the current sportscar designers, and you were allowed to make up your own rules and regs, you would see some pretty weird and wonderful designs appear on track.
Sorry Robbo, but the thought of 33 DW's starting at Indy is very scary, and should never be allowed to happen. We can argue till the cows come home about the performance of this car on track, and how it defies conventional thinking, but the simple fact that it (as Fax said) rolled like a beer keg after getting tagged on the rear, which would normally only send a car into a spin, not a roll, surely is enough evidence to suggest that the car can lap quickly, but in the heat of battle with other cars, is quite frankly dangerous.
As far as a more open design 500kg class is concerned, this is more appealing, and is possibly the way to go, rather than that of the DW.