Russ, I expect you are right in your hypothesis and each to his own etc. (BTW, nothing wrong with Erta but damn she makes me feel old.)
I have to say, I fall into the traditionalists/zealots camp, along with H and his pals, although personally I did not see H smite anything with an arse bone or whatever it was.
Mind you H, the girl from Staffordshire? in your party had an amazing gift of being able to guess peoples birthdays. She was only one day out with me! Incredible, tho I am surprised she could understand a word I said given the wretched state of me that friday night.